Discussion:
[users] Is repoforge dead?
Maarten van der Rijst
2014-12-31 10:27:20 UTC
Permalink
I was wondering the same thing. According to CentOS wiki
rpmforge/reprofoge is not maintained anymore.

http://wiki.centos.org/AdditionalResources/Repositories


But haven't seen an announcement on the website that that the repo is
dead? And all current howto's etc still seem to be pointing to use
rpmforge/reproforge.

greetings,

Maarten
I am not seeing packages updated such as clamav for example, and list
emails are virtually non-existent.
Is repoforge dead?
Regards,
T. Greggs
--
This message has been scanned for viruses and
dangerous content by *MailScanner* <http://www.mailscanner.info/>, and is
believed to be clean.
_______________________________________________
users mailing list
http://lists.repoforge.org/mailman/listinfo/users
Dag Wieers
2014-12-31 12:02:55 UTC
Permalink
Post by Maarten van der Rijst
I am not seeing packages updated such as clamav for example, and list
emails are virtually non-existent.
Is repoforge dead?
I was wondering the same thing. According to CentOS wiki
rpmforge/reprofoge is not maintained anymore.
http://wiki.centos.org/AdditionalResources/Repositories
But haven't seen an announcement on the website that that the repo is
dead? And all current howto's etc still seem to be pointing to use
rpmforge/reproforge.
Even I don't know the status of the project :)

Let's presume it is dead, until proven otherwise.
--
Dag
Steve Huff
2014-12-31 14:16:15 UTC
Permalink
the way I see it, repoforge has three major assets:

1) the build and mirror infrastructure. the mirrors are still functioning just fine (thank you David and others!), but the build system is limited by the time and energy Dag can devote to it.

2) the codebase. there's a huge treasure of specfiles at https://github.com/repoforge/rpms, and those still get updated periodically by maintainers. that is also the part of the project where it is easiest for new people to help; also, the specs are still valuable regardless of whether there are up-to-date packages being built.

3) the people. we have some smart, dedicated people associated with this project, both maintainers and users. I would be sad to see those people drift away.

repoforge in its traditional form does not work without all three of these assets; however, I have been thinking for a while that the next evolution of repoforge might look something like the following:

a repository of specfiles (we already have that), and in addition a turnkey process by which anybody could set up their own build system (a Vagrantfile maybe? a VM image? a Puppet module?). rather than having a single centralized build and mirror service, anybody who wanted to make use of repoforge packages would spin up their build system, either ad hoc if they just want a few packages, or maybe leave it running all the time.

I personally want this because I use repoforge packages in my own infrastructure, and since I'm the builder I can sign them myself without needing Dag's blessing :) however, clearly I haven't gotten around to building this next evolution in the past two years that I've been thinking about it.

we are on the cusp of a new year, and now is the time for resolutions, so here is my resolution:

if one single person, either a maintainer or a user (or some stranger who reads this email), says that they also want this next evolution that I've described and that they are willing to help to any degree at all, then I will work on this project during 2015. anything that we produce while working on this project will be free for all to use.

so, there you have it. feel free either to reply to the list, or to email me off-list. if you kind of like the idea, and would be willing to help if it were different somehow, then email me anyway; I like the idea as it is, but I am open to changes and suggestions.

I wish you all a happy New Year!

-steve

p.s. if nobody wants to help, then I will still get around to doing this work someday, but I make no promises concerning a timetable :)
--
http://five.sentenc.es
Post by Dag Wieers
Post by Maarten van der Rijst
I am not seeing packages updated such as clamav for example, and list
emails are virtually non-existent.
Is repoforge dead?
I was wondering the same thing. According to CentOS wiki
rpmforge/reprofoge is not maintained anymore.
http://wiki.centos.org/AdditionalResources/Repositories
But haven't seen an announcement on the website that that the repo is
dead? And all current howto's etc still seem to be pointing to use
rpmforge/reproforge.
Even I don't know the status of the project :)
Let's presume it is dead, until proven otherwise.
--
Dag
_______________________________________________
users mailing list
http://lists.repoforge.org/mailman/listinfo/users
Always Learning
2014-12-31 23:23:19 UTC
Permalink
Een Gelukkig Nieuwjaar aan iedereen (ook aan mijn buurvrouwje) en
natuurlijk ook aan Dag,

Happy New Year to everyone.
.....................

Agreed.
Post by Steve Huff
I personally want this because I use repoforge packages in my own infrastructure, and since I'm the builder I can sign them myself without needing Dag's blessing :) however, clearly I haven't gotten around to building this next evolution in the past two years that I've been thinking about it.
Me too but some are out-of-date.
Post by Steve Huff
if one single person, either a maintainer or a user (or some stranger who reads this email), says that they also want this next evolution that I've described and that they are willing to help to any degree at all, then I will work on this project during 2015. anything that we produce while working on this project will be free for all to use.
Agreed.
Post by Steve Huff
so, there you have it. feel free either to reply to the list, or to email me off-list. if you kind of like the idea, and would be willing to help if it were different somehow, then email me anyway; I like the idea as it is, but I am open to changes and suggestions.
Yes, let us save, preserve and resurrect (revitalise, update) the Dag
repo. If many of us can do a little, then under the leadership of Steve
Repoforge can regain its rightful place as a Linux treasury of
dependable, if not also invaluable, material.

I am sure Dag, now time limited, will help, advise and guide us to make
repoforge an invaluable deposit of Linux (for me, Centos/Red Hat)
binaries. Let us start a community effort for 2015.

With everyone working together we can, collectively, make a beneficial
difference to everyone.

What are the hosting arrangements for repoforge - who presently funds
the servers ?

Paul
An European Englishman
(and absolutely pro-EU)
--
-------------------------------------------------------
100% exclusively Linux (Centos). No M$ Windoze here.
-------------------------------------------------------
David Hrbáč
2015-01-01 13:23:32 UTC
Permalink
Hi to all,

Repoforge is not dead, I just had no time to push the updates. We have
everything up and running. DNS, mirrors, mirrorlist, mailman, git
repository, cnucnu instance to discover new upstream sources releases,
etc. We also have the trigger on the repository to start builders with
every commit (via XMMP).

We need:
- a new signing key
- run the rebuild and build process
- resign the packages with the new key
- create new release RPM
- start working on EL7 tree
- finally make the RF community project

I'm sorry, this is my fault, since I'm responsible for not delivering
all these points. Last year I was involved in starting Czech national
supercomputer, that's my excuse.

I'd like to create the group of people to maintain the RF. We have the
list of task to do, so we can re-start the project.

Maybe we can start this month creating the group, make the first
e-meeting, distribute the task.

Anyone interested?

Thanks,
David Hrbáč
I am not seeing packages updated such as clamav for example, and list
emails are virtually non-existent.
Is repoforge dead?
Regards,
T. Greggs
--
This message has been scanned for viruses and
dangerous content by *MailScanner* <http://www.mailscanner.info/>, and is
believed to be clean.
_______________________________________________
users mailing list
http://lists.repoforge.org/mailman/listinfo/users
Loading...